Demand & Show Cause Notice (SCN) Handling is the full-spectrum legal and factual defence of a registered taxpayer during GST demand adjudication under Sections 73, 74, and 75 of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 142 of the CGST Rules. It is the stage at which the department moves beyond scrutiny and audit and formally proposes recovery of tax, interest, and penalty — through a pre-SCN intimation in Form DRC-01A, a formal show cause notice in Form DRC-01, a reply in Form DRC-06, personal hearing, and ultimately a demand order in Form DRC-07. What is decided here decisively shapes the outcome — any issue lost at this stage can only be recovered through a costly, time-bound appeal with pre-deposit under Section 107.
SCNs issued under Section 73 deal with tax not paid, short-paid, or ITC wrongly availed where there is no element of fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts — with lower penalty exposure and a three-year limitation. SCNs under Section 74 invoke allegations of fraud or suppression, extending the limitation to five years and pushing penalty exposure up to 100% of tax. There are also specialised notices under Section 76 (tax collected but not paid), Section 122 (penalty), Section 129 (detention of goods and conveyances), Section 130 (confiscation), and Rule 86B / 88C / 88D (mismatch-driven intimations). Each of these has its own procedural rhythm, limitation clock, and defence template — and mixing them up is one of the fastest ways to lose a case.
We offer end-to-end Demand & SCN Handling Services — from technical analysis of every notice received, strategic decision on DRC-01A settlement vs full contest, drafting of DRC-06 replies with reconciliations and case law, representation at personal hearings, adjudication defence under Sections 73 / 74 / 75, review of DRC-07 orders, evaluation of appeal viability, and seamless filing of Section 107 first appeal — so that every SCN is either closed favourably at adjudication stage, settled commercially on your terms, or carried forward with a clean, appeal-ready record.
Sec 73 / 74
Core demand provisions
Rule 142
Procedural demand rule
10% / 100%
Penalty – Sec 73 vs 74
Section 107
First appeal pathway
Laws & Frameworks We Work Under
CGST Act – Sec 73 (Non-Fraud)
CGST Act – Sec 74 (Fraud)
CGST Act – Sec 75 (General)
CGST Act – Sec 76 / 122
CGST Act – Sec 129 / 130
CGST Rules – Rule 142
Forms DRC-01A / 01 / 03 / 06 / 07
Section 107 (Appeal)
FAQs on Demand & Show Cause Notice Handling
What is the difference between DRC-01A and DRC-01?
DRC-01A is a pre-show-cause intimation issued under Rule 142(1A) of the CGST Rules, where the proper officer communicates the tax, interest, and penalty ascertained as payable before issuing a formal SCN. It offers the taxpayer an opportunity to accept and pay the amount through Form DRC-03 — avoiding a formal adjudication and, often, reducing penalty exposure. DRC-01, by contrast, is the formal show cause notice under Section 73 or 74 initiating the adjudication proceedings. Once DRC-01 is issued, a structured reply in DRC-06 becomes mandatory, followed by personal hearing and a formal order in DRC-07.
How long do we get to reply to a DRC-01 SCN?
The time period to file a reply in Form DRC-06 is typically specified in the SCN itself, and is generally at least 30 days from the date of service of the notice. The officer is obliged to provide reasonable time and a personal hearing before passing any adverse order. In practice, short extensions are often granted where the taxpayer requests them in writing, well before the original deadline, with reasons. A hurried or incomplete reply is significantly more damaging than a reasonably extended, fully reconciled one — we plan the timeline around what it takes to put a complete reply on record.
What happens if we do not reply to a SCN?
Non-response to a DRC-01 SCN is one of the most damaging things a taxpayer can do. Under Section 75, where no reply is filed despite due notice and opportunity of hearing, the proper officer can proceed to pass an order on the basis of the material available on record. This typically results in an adverse DRC-07 confirming the full demand with interest and maximum penalty. The taxpayer is then left only with the first-appeal route under Section 107 — with pre-deposit, strict limitation, and an uphill task of introducing evidence that could have been raised at SCN stage. Filing even a basic reply and seeking adjournment is far better than silence.
Can we pay tax during SCN proceedings to reduce penalty?
Yes. Both Sections 73 and 74 provide structured incentives for early payment. Under Section 73(5) / 73(8), payment of tax and interest before the SCN or within 30 days of the SCN results in no penalty. Under Section 74(5) / 74(8), similar early payment attracts reduced penalties of 15% and 25% respectively, escalating thereafter. For issues that are factually or legally weak, strategic DRC-03 payment often saves significant quantum. For issues with real merit, we structure payment differently — paying only undisputed amounts or making payment "under protest" — to preserve the legal position for appeal without giving up settlement benefits on the conceded parts.
When is Section 74 invocation inappropriate?
Section 74 is meant for cases involving fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts with an intent to evade tax. It is not meant for routine disputes on classification, valuation, interpretation of law, genuine ITC mismatches, or clerical errors. Courts have repeatedly clarified that mere non-payment or short-payment of tax, without a specific allegation and finding of fraud / suppression backed by evidence, is not enough to invoke Section 74. In many SCNs, the department invokes Section 74 reflexively to extend limitation or increase penalty — we push back on such invocation at the reply stage itself, since a successful re-characterisation under Section 73 significantly reduces both exposure and litigation cost.
What is the role of personal hearing in SCN adjudication?
Personal hearing is a cornerstone of natural justice in GST adjudication. Section 75(4) specifically mandates a personal hearing where a request is received in writing or where any adverse decision is contemplated against the taxpayer. The hearing is the opportunity to explain oral nuances that the written reply cannot fully capture, clarify officer's questions, introduce additional evidence, and sometimes narrow down the real issues in dispute. Skipping or treating it casually is a mistake — a properly prepared, well-argued personal hearing often decisively shifts the tone of the final order, even where the written reply was already on record.
What happens if multiple SCNs are issued for different years?
Large taxpayers routinely receive multiple SCNs — often one per financial year, across different GSTINs, and sometimes on overlapping issues. These need to be handled through a centralised framework — a master tracker of all open SCNs, a consistent set of legal and factual positions, common working papers that feed all replies, and coordinated personal hearings. Where the same issue appears across years, consolidated submissions can be prepared so that the officer hears the same narrative. Fragmented handling — with different consultants for different years — almost always results in inconsistent positions that hurt the taxpayer at the appellate stage.
What happens after a DRC-07 demand order?
A DRC-07 demand order crystallises the tax, interest, and penalty payable and becomes recoverable after 30 days from the date of service. The taxpayer can either pay the demand through DRC-03 and close the matter, or file a first appeal in Form GST APL-01 under Section 107 within three months (extendable by one month) from the date of service of the order, along with a 10% pre-deposit of the disputed tax amount. Once a valid appeal with pre-deposit is filed, recovery of the balance is automatically stayed under Section 107(7). Every SCN-handling engagement is run with an eye on how cleanly the record will carry over into the appellate stage if required.
Turn Every GST Show Cause Notice Into a Managed, Defensible Outcome
Partner with our specialists for end-to-end Demand & SCN Handling — DRC-01A strategy, DRC-06 drafting, personal hearings, DRC-07 review, and Section 107 appeal — all under one roof.
Talk to an Expert